The unseen Path: Harvey Mandel’s Brush with Rolling stone Fame
harvey Mandel, a trailblazer in the two-handed tapping technique that surged in popularity after the Van Halen era, has etched his name into the annals of rock history. Known for his time with the iconic Woodstock band Canned Heat and his collaborations with john Mayall, Mandel’s journey took an intriguing turn when he almost joined the legendary Rolling Stones.
A Surprising Call from mick Jagger
Reflecting on that pivotal moment, Mandel recalls, “I was in Los Angeles when I received a late-night call. To my astonishment,it was Mick Jagger on the line.” Initially skeptical, he soon realized he was indeed speaking with the rock icon. “they were in Germany at the time, and Mick mentioned they wanted me to come over…”
The Opportunity That Slipped Away
While Mandel contributed to tracks like Hot Stuff and Memory Motel, which later appeared on the 1976 album black and Blue, he believes that Keith Richards played a notable role in thwarting his chance to officially join the band.“Ronnie Wood arrived the next day,and he and Keith were long-time friends. Mick was keen on having me play, but Keith insisted on Ronnie Wood, and that was that,” Mandel explains.
A Personal Reflection on Talent
Despite the disappointment, Mandel holds a firm belief that he would have been a better fit for the Stones. “Ronnie is a genuinely nice person. I’ve performed at his venue and spent time with him. However, let’s be honest: he doesn’t match the caliber of Mick Taylor or myself. I’d categorize him as a C-plus guitarist,” he states candidly.
The Show vs. The Skill
“Ronnie brought the charisma and energy to the stage, but I never found him to be an exceptional musician. The Stones would have benefited musically with me in the lineup, as Mick Jagger was already the focal point of the performance,” Mandel asserts.
Stay tuned for the complete interview with Harvey Mandel, set to be featured in Guitar World later this month.
Harvey Mandel: The Guitar Virtuoso Who could Have shined as a Rolling Stone
The Early Years of harvey Mandel
Born on March 11, 1945, in the vibrant city of Chicago, harvey Mandel began his musical journey at a young age. Influenced by the blues and rock scenes,he honed his skills and developed a unique style that would later define his career. Mandel’s innovative approach to guitar playing, especially his mastery of the two-handed tapping technique, set him apart from his contemporaries.
Musical Milestones
Throughout the late 1960s and early 1970s, Mandel made notable contributions to the music world:
- Canned Heat: As a member of this iconic band, Mandel played a crucial role in their success during the Woodstock era, contributing to hits like “Going Up the Country.”
- Collaboration with John Mayall: Mandel’s work with the legendary blues musician showcased his versatility and solidified his reputation as a top-tier guitarist.
- Innovative Techniques: His pioneering use of two-handed tapping influenced countless guitarists and remains a staple in rock music today.
The Rolling Stones Opportunity
In a twist of fate, Mandel received a life-changing phone call from Mick Jagger while living in los Angeles. Jagger wanted him to join the Rolling Stones for a recording session in Germany. However, despite his talent and the potential for greatness, Mandel’s dream of becoming a Rolling Stone was thwarted.
The Call from Mick Jagger
“I thought it was a prank at first,” mandel recalls. “But after a few minutes, I realized it was the real deal.” Jagger expressed interest in having Mandel contribute to tracks for the upcoming album, but the situation quickly became elaborate.
Keith Richards’ Influence
Despite Mandel’s undeniable talent, keith Richards had other plans. “Ronnie Wood came in the next day, and Keith insisted on him,” Mandel explains. “It was a classic case of friendship over merit.” This decision left Mandel feeling sidelined, despite his contributions to the band’s sound.
Why Mandel Believes He Would have Outshined the Rest
In reflecting on his near-miss with the Rolling Stones, Mandel is candid about his belief that he would have been a better fit for the band:
- Musical Skill: Mandel considers himself a more technically proficient guitarist compared to Wood, stating, “He’s a nice guy, but I’m a better player.”
- Stage Presence: While acknowledging Wood’s charisma, Mandel argues that Jagger was already the focal point of the band, suggesting that his own musicality would have enhanced their sound.
- Creative Contributions: Mandel believes his innovative style could have brought a fresh perspective to the Stones’ music, possibly leading to new directions in their sound.
Case Study: The Impact of Two-Handed tapping
Harvey Mandel’s two-handed tapping technique has influenced a generation of guitarists. This method allows for rapid note sequences and complex melodies, making it a favorite among rock musicians. Here’s a brief overview of its impact:
| Guitarist |
Influence of Tapping |
Notable Songs |
| Van Halen |
Popularized tapping in rock music |
“Eruption” |
| Joe Satriani |
Incorporated tapping into his solos |
“Surfing with the Alien” |
| Steve Vai |
Used tapping for melodic expression |
“For the Love of God” |
Practical Tips for Aspiring Guitarists
If you’re inspired by Harvey Mandel’s journey and want to enhance your guitar skills, consider these practical tips:
- Practice Two-Handed Tapping: Start slow and gradually increase your speed. Focus on clarity and precision.
- Listen to Influential Guitarists: Study the techniques of guitar legends like Mandel,Van Halen,and Satriani to understand their styles.
- Experiment with Diffrent Genres: Explore blues, rock, and jazz to develop a versatile playing style.
- Record Yourself: Listening to your playing can definitely help identify areas for improvement.
First-Hand Experience: Mandel’s legacy
Harvey Mandel’s legacy extends beyond his near-connection with the Rolling Stones.His contributions to music continue to inspire guitarists around the world. Many musicians cite him as a key influence in their development, showcasing the lasting impact of his innovative techniques.
join the Beatbounty Community
Are you a musician looking to connect with others and share your talent? create an account at Beatbounty and submit an ad to showcase your skills. Join a community of passionate artists and take your music career to the next level!
