Guitar Player is wrapping up 2025 by revisiting 25 of your favorite articles from the past year. We appreciate your support throughout the year and are excited to bring you more captivating stories in 2026.
when Don McLean penned “American Pie” and released it as a single in 1971, he achieved more than just a chart-topping hit. He crafted a timeless piece that has continued to resonate with audiences for over 55 years. This song has become an anthem cherished by listeners across generations.
The track takes listeners on a vivid journey through the social upheaval and transformations of 1960s America. For many years, McLean was famously tight-lipped about the song’s cryptic lyrics, choosing to let its enigma linger.
Despite his reticence regarding the song’s meaning, “American Pie” has remained a highlight of his live performances, captivating audiences and encouraging sing-alongs.
Interestingly, even with its immense popularity-second only to his 1972 classic “Vincent”-McLean had not performed it with another artist until a memorable collaboration with country superstar Garth brooks in 1997. At that time, Brooks was riding high with diamond-certified albums like No Fences (1990) and Ropin’ the Wind (1991), and he had just completed a record-breaking concert in Central Park.
This context makes the recent performance by rising star Jessie Murph on September 27 notably noteworthy.
During her sold-out show at the Shrine Auditorium in Los Angeles, Murph invited McLean on stage for a rare rendition of “American Pie,” marking her as only the second artist in 55 years to share the stage with him for this iconic song.
The 20-year-old singer-songwriter expressed her excitement on Instagram,stating,”I am filled with gratitude today. Last night was magical and incredible; I feel like the luckiest girl on earth.”
Murph’s tribute to the song underscores its enduring significance in American culture. While the lyrics reflect the tumultuous events of the 1960s, McLean, who recorded “American Pie” using a Martin D-28 acoustic guitar, has shared that the song was born from a profound sense of loss experienced during that era.
“In ‘American Pie,’ things are heading in the wrong direction,” he explained in a 2015 interview with christie’s catalog, coinciding with the auction of his handwritten 18-page manuscript of the song’s lyrics for $1.2 million. “Life is becoming less idyllic. Whether you see that as right or wrong, it is indeed, in a way, a morality song.”
He elaborated further in an interview with People that same year, lamenting, “There is no poetry and very little romance in anything anymore, so it is really like the last phase of ‘American Pie.’”
“Life is becoming less idyllic. I don’t know whether you consider that wrong or right, but it is a morality song in a sense.”
– Don McLean
While McLean has occasionally shared insights about the song’s themes, he has recently offered more in-depth explanations, particularly in a 2022 documentary and subsequent interviews. He discussed the song’s ties to the end of the “happy 1950s,” the divisive nature of the 1960s, and the tragic plane crash that claimed the lives of rock and roll legends Buddy Holly, Ritchie Valens, and the Big Bopper.
In the documentary, mclean revealed his hesitance to clarify the characters referenced in his lyrics. As an example, he identified James Dean in one line, indicating that he was not being entirely vague.
“I mentioned James Dean in the song,” he noted to Forbes.”If I meant elvis or Bob Dylan, I would have used their names.”
He further clarified that the “thorny crown” worn by the king in his lyrics suggests he was not referring to Presley.
“If you want to think the king is Elvis you can, but the king in my song has a thorny crown. That’s Jesus Christ.”
Additionally, he employs a playful tone in his lyrics, referencing “Lenin read a book on marx” as a nod to John Lennon, whom he noted had an interest in Marxist ideas.
Though, “American Pie” is also deeply personal and tragic.McLean has expressed that its emotional essence stems from an early grief encapsulated in the song’s opening verse, which reflects on the death of Holly and “his widowed bride.”
“I wanted to capture and say something that was almost unspeakable.It’s indescribable.”
– Don McLean
At just 15 years old, mclean had a premonition about his father’s impending death. When he confided in his grandmother, she asked why he felt that way. “Because it’s going to happen,” he replied.
Shortly thereafter, his father passed away “right in front of me,” he recounted to The Guardian. “I cried for two years. I blamed myself.”
this profound loss partly explains his long-standing reluctance to discuss the lyrics-he struggled to articulate his overwhelming grief in a song that encapsulated all he felt was lost, both personally and within the fabric of America.
“I wanted to capture and say something that was almost unspeakable,” he shared with the news outlet. “It’s indescribable.”
